I think many readers will agree with me that TPF 3 has largely been a success, as compared to TPF2, which was little more than a joke. We’ve been glued to the TV ever since the hilarious auditions. I think that was a great way to hype up the show. We’ve seen a better pool of singers this time round, and it’s generally been far better organized and a lot more professional. Kudos to the organizers for pulling up their socks. It all comes to an end tonight, with the winner walking away with Ksh 5 million.
The Pros
- I liked the theme nights, costumes and décor for the hosts and contestants
- The live bands, Kidum and his band, and the jazz maestro Aaron Rimbui were excellent!
- Judge Ian Mbugua doing what he does best, being himself.
The Cons
- MICH!! Seriously, who the hell picked this doofus to host the show? He is TERRIBLE on so many levels!! Mich tries hard to feign humour, which clearly he doesn’t possess. There is zero chemistry between him and his co-host Sheila Mwanyigha and this ends up watering down her efforts to be professional. The beef that he tried to create with Judge Ian was laughable, and in a battle of wits, let’s just say that he didn’t arrive at the battle with enough firepower to even faze Ian Mbugua. The beef that was there between Gaetano and Ian in TPF1 had us transfixed. EABL, tafadhali yaani pris, DO NOT HAVE THIS MAN IN TPF4!
- Whoever was in charge of Sheila Mwanyigha’s make up and costumes seriously has something against her. Sheila is a beautiful woman, but has been made to look like a clown with some utterly laughable hairdos, from a pet dog on her head, to Morticia from The Addam’s family, to a peacock to sijui what else. Sheila, find that person, and call me to help you beat him/her up coz enyewe, that was malice ad infinitum.
For those of you on Twitter, I’m sure you’ve been closely observing what has come to be known as #ChukiFM, where a bunch of tweepo (people on Twitter…get with the flow!) critique (and in some cases, massacre) the contestants, hosts and judges on their attire and performances. There have also been some level headed analysis on the better part. (Also check out #TPF3)
Let me do an individual assessment of all the contestants.
1. Caroline (Uganda)
Carol is a talented performer. She has a great voice and bewitching charm and knows how to work the audience using her best ASSets. Banange!! However , the comely lady from Uganda has faltered over the past two or so weeks after putting out several strong performances since the beginning of the show. In terms of musical talent, she does not have what it takes to win TPF3, but she has immense potential to be a successful recording artiste, and I foresee a bright future for her.
2. Ng’ang’a-lito
Ng’ang’a has been TPF3’s version of Hemedi from TPF2. That less talented performer who, due to his loyal female fans, didn’t leave the competition as early as he should have. In all honesty though, despite many horrendous performances, Ng’ang’a-lito has produced a few sterling performances that led us all to believe that he really can sing, if only he puts his comical theatrics aside. The fact that he has been saved by the audience several times already, despite all attempts by the judges to get rid of him by having 5 contestants on probation, shows that he stands a strong chance of winning TPF3 tonight.
I’ve had a good laugh this past week watching Ng’ang’a’s appeals for votes from the audience. Whereas other contestants appeal for votes saying “I know I’m a good singer…” etc, Ng’ang’a feels jack for all that. All he wants is THE MONEY! “I can smell the money! Super-lito plus the 5 million-ito…” I’m tempted to say that he conforms to his ethnic stereotype, but we all know that tribal jokes are a no-go zone in Kenya these days.
3. Patricia (Kenya)
Patricia has been, in my opinion, the strongest contestant ever since the beginning of the show. At some point, she was the clear favourite to win the Ksh 5 million. She has only been on probation once during the competition (save for last weekend where all contestants were on probation). She has wowed us with a string of brilliant performances, and she still remains my pick to win TPF3.
However, she will not win the competition. She earned herself stinging criticism from Kenyans on Facebook after she voted to save Ng’ang’a and have Debarl eliminated from the competition.
This is where I wonder which part of their anatomy is involved in some people’s thinking process, for I’m convinced that their mental faculties had taken a hiatus from their responsibilities. This is an INDIVIDUAL competition. The contestants did not go there to make friends or to have loyalties of whatever nature. They have to formulate strategies that will enhance their chances of winning. That’s what a competition is all about. All contestants knew from the day that they walked in, that at some point, they will be voted out by their fellow contestants.
There is no doubt that Debarl is talented, the man can sing! But after his below-par rendition of Nameless’ “Deadly” (which rivals Ng’ang’a’s rendition of a San Fan Thomas song for terrible-ness) he was bound to leave either way. What Patricia did was to employ logic, and a winning strategy to eliminate the stronger contestant, hoping that later on Ng’ang’a’s musical journey will come to an end. If Debarl had stayed in the competition, it would have made things very difficult for Patricia later on. If I had been in Patricia’s shoes, I would have done the same thing, and I’m sure that many of you agree with me. Sometimes in life, one has to make difficult, painful decisions.
4. Alpha (Rwanda)
As things stand right now, Alpha stands the strongest chance of winning TPF3. He s a clear favourite among female voters, more so for his looks than his musical talent. I’m not trying to imply that he is not a good singer, that he is. My main criticism is that he is a shouter. The same view has been expressed by the judges. There is a clear difference between singing and shouting, and he is more of a professional in the latter. When it comes to reggae songs, Alpha is brilliant! His original composition was a joy to behold, in fact he earned himself a standing ovation from the audience after his performance. But his musical talent is only in one genre of music, reggae. Compared to Patricia, she is strong in several genres.
My Predictions
Two schools of thought exist as to what is supposed to happen tonight, as compared to what will actually happen.
Going purely by musical talent, my fellow tweeps suggest that the results SHOULD be as follows
- Patricia (winner)
- Alpha (1st Runner Up)
- Caroline (2nd Runner Up)
- Ng’ang’a
However, the second school of thought has it that the organizers of TPF3, East Africa Breweries Ltd (EABL), have to get their money’s worth in the end. This, after all, is a marketing venture for them. They already have a strong presence in Kenya and Tanzania, I dunno how well they’re doing in Uganda, but there is immense potential in Rwanda which is the next market that they intend to venture into. Therefore, it is in their best interests for Alpha to win the competition. I’m not trying to imply that EABL will rig the votes, but the fact that Alpha is the clear favourite amongst the female audience works perfectly in their favour. Ng’ang’a-lito is also another favourite amongst older female viewers and the gay community.
Therefore, the winner of TPF3 will not necessarily be the one who deserves to win based on musical talent.
Therefore, according to some of the members of #ChukiFM, myself included, the final results WILL be as follows.
- Alpha/Ng’ang’a (on the basis of votes from female voters. Alpha will probably get the swing vote from Tanzania, who have no contestant left in the competition, while Kenyan ladies have been furiously voting in favour of Ng’ang’a)
- Caroline (Ugandans will definitely vote for her)
- Patricia (Ng’ang’a will have split the Kenyan votes to her detriment)
So, what do you make of my predictions? Feel free to share yours.
All in all, big ups to all the tweeps in #ChukiFM, (mko wengi, na mnajijua) for keeping this competition lively and entertaining! Special commendation goes to the big wise man from the mountain, the soothsayer himself, @mountainous for having all his probation predictions spot on during the entire competition.
Tune in to the grand finale tonight, only on Twitter.
A.O.B
But of course I had to throw in some Lumi! You know I had to!
Eye candy! Forget the tu outfit, this woman is BEAUTIFUL!!!! Illuminata illuminated me, nikamulika, until she was er…eliminated. I cried that day, karibu I ran to her send off party at K1 to get Christian’s scrawny paws off her.
In other news…
It’s fair to say that we have been entertained by the contestants who appeared during the commercial breaks. The Michael Jackson wannabe (“I remember…when we…fell in loooooove…”) the Rwandan guy with “Baby Gar Baby Gar Baby gaaaaaaaar…..oooooooh Baby Gar!” and the Ugandan rastafari (gildigildigildi..brrrrrrrrbbaba) eh…do you think they got paid by EABL for being used in the adverts? I think they SHOULD be paid!!
What’s on my Playlist?
The Whisper Song – Beenie Man.





October 11, 2009 at 1:46 pm
Thanks Archer for the mention but it was use of simple judgement rather than mystic powers that helped in making probation predictions. I steered clearly off predictions when it came to eviction and the eventual winner because its rarely based on rational criteria like actual ability to sing. Its more based on how the voting public sees you (and we all know who are the majority voters!)
I agree Alpha is the most popular contestant and will probably win if his fans don’t get complacent and forget to vote – remember how Linda Muthama’s fans in TPF1 assumed she would be handed the prize without them voting whereas Valerie fans like myself were voting furiously.
Patricia like Kaz before her has been dealt a rather raw deal by the general bitching of Kenyans (yaani chukiFM) if the producers had wanted an all rounder they should have varied the themes A bit more just like Idols does so it doesn’t give too much advantage to those contestants who are able to stick to their comfort zones you realize Alpha was put on probation on the two episodes he didn’t do a reggae song but without doubt his reggae performances are absolutely breathtaking.
October 11, 2009 at 6:31 pm
Kwani you had leakage?
But I am so glad that Dr Mich is gone from my screen!!
October 11, 2009 at 6:35 pm
hehe..ur predictions hv been proved good..good good…
Meanwhile Chuki FM has been a blast…cant wait for the next edition…..
October 11, 2009 at 6:54 pm
Uko on point ka dot juu ya i.
Totally true will miss #Chukifm They are starting the new dance show as a program on #chukifm add in MiL (Mother in Law) and the Chakacha show
Because I’m Kenyan I had to add this Mitch ako down ka basement ya devo.
October 11, 2009 at 7:53 pm
Great predictions Arch! I however stand by Mich kuliko that Gaetano dude. Half the time his wit goes awry… and his delivery sucks sometimes lakini there is a ka-something there. Just me thots…
October 11, 2009 at 8:19 pm
*sigh* Now what will I do on Sundays… all I had going in my life was Chuki Fm! Whose oversized head gear (aka juala fiasco of 2009) shall I comment on? Woe is me….
October 11, 2009 at 8:25 pm
Man, ALpha deserved it.I love tusker project fame….I knew it from Day one! the guy has a voice and he is very strong.Go Boy, i am you no.1 fan. Huggs man.Xxx
October 11, 2009 at 8:29 pm
Like Jaramogi once said about Moi…”yeye ni kama giraffe, anaona mbali” Leo uliona mbali
October 11, 2009 at 8:35 pm
predictions were spot on!
Alpha was sure to win in mine and patricia got her well earned #4. Debarl didn’t deserve what she handed him. If she played fairer,
we would have had 3 Kenyans in the final 4….maybe..
the ugandan and rwandese definately deserve to be paid!
October 11, 2009 at 8:37 pm
i weep for patricia. yaani lumi had to get a mention! wawawa! for the on spot prediction, i really hope you get to meet her some day. #chukifm was a blast, mich was an punda shimo, performances by faculty, judge ian were a great ending. i pray pat grows bigger than alpha
October 11, 2009 at 8:48 pm
if patrica was good enough to be number 1,she shouldnt have used used such strategy.if you are good enough,u dont get moved by worthy opponents,u stand up and hesabika.
October 12, 2009 at 6:52 am
I feel you, she deserved the position she got…
that made my night and Alpha crowned it
October 14, 2009 at 10:46 am
Don’t blame the individual, blame the system. Coz why would contestants be allowed to vote each other out? Patricia didn’t invent the system!
October 12, 2009 at 4:03 am
I think out of all the contestants, Patricia had the best vocal talent, but she lacked that ooomph when it came to performing, but 4th place was just rough wa!!
All she won was a laptop and a voucher for counselling which she will clearly need to recover from this.
I do not get what the drama was about because in my opinion, ng’ang’alito has better vocals than Debarl.
But Alpha emerged the victor, and his humility just made him even more deserving.
October 21, 2009 at 2:37 pm
alpha was not humble at all.
did u c how he used to deal with his fellow contestants?
i dint like him from day 1.
i wish ng’ang’alito took the money; i was touched by his humble background, zm sure no 1 else was a hustler like him.
October 12, 2009 at 6:06 am
Congratulations: Great predictions you made and you were spot on with the outcome
October 12, 2009 at 6:21 am
Just one comment…How did you know Nganga was a favourite of the gay community eh?
October 13, 2009 at 5:15 pm
ummm…and kwach of easy fm mentioned it on radio while interviewing Nganga. He asked Nganga how he felt about having massive support from the gay community and Nganga didnt seem to mind(a vote is a vote).
October 12, 2009 at 7:35 am
Wah!
Nice one!
Alpha can sing to me ANYTIME!
Patricia who?
That mama almost made me sleep with that rendition of “watu na viatu”
October 12, 2009 at 7:39 am
Alpha stood a better chance of winning till the last minute and for sure he deserved it, no rigging or anything else but the truth is that he won transparently
October 12, 2009 at 7:43 am
I loved me some Illuminata. Thanks for that picture Archer. You will be remembered in heaven for that!
Now.. I don’t know the vocal range of Ng’ang’a but at least he has proved that Kenyans will vote for anything that moves its hips.
October 12, 2009 at 9:11 am
I’ve watched two episodes. The first, Ng’ang’a sang some song and to me sounded like it was straight from the Kikuyu songbook ‘Nyimbo Cia Kuinira Ngai’.
The second, they made Sheila wear some wet looking black creature around her neck.
I’m not into reality shows, but must say, loved reading Chukifm when I caught it on.
Great review Archer. I get the whole picture despite not having watched the show much.
October 12, 2009 at 9:35 am
It was so nice seeing Alpha wining,Nganga was likewise good,but he could not reach Alpha,God gave Alpha the best voice and he made good use of it,
we the supporters of him,were very happy seeing him win,
God bless him as he will be going back home to Rwanda,
October 14, 2009 at 1:53 pm
those who disagree ‘wacha wivu’
October 14, 2009 at 2:33 pm
Wivu juu ya nini? Do we have to agree with you? Everyone is entitled to their own point of view.
October 12, 2009 at 12:09 pm
I can bow down to your predictions, quite on point.
Now can you predict who the 4 ministers in Ocampos list are…………….
October 12, 2009 at 2:38 pm
Thumbs up ALPHA.
Ssh……Guess Wat? Seeing Alpha win was a thing worth rejoicing.This guy had what it takes and much more i guess am right by saying that his humility actually played a big role to see him to the top.
congrats!
October 12, 2009 at 3:07 pm
Dude, you nailed this sucker to the wall,
I shall indeed miss the #tpf3 sessions, there is a new dance show starting on 18th, i hope that shall be better than KTNs dance whatever that flopped major.
October 12, 2009 at 5:15 pm
Wow man chukifm were spot on…You should have seen Patricia, she was stunned like a deer in headlights…
Its tru that Alpha and Ng’ang’a had a fanatical following from both male and female fans.
Ng’ang’a did well on on finale show, but was a joker during other perfomances….so the guy was just messing around….ati telling guys to sing nugu nene!!!…
October 13, 2009 at 5:29 pm
Fantastic review! Patricia deserved to win the show. Her time will come and her star will continue to shine even brighter!
October 14, 2009 at 10:49 am
That I have no doubt about. At least there’s less pressure on her than on Alpha. She can quietly go about making her album and it will be a success.
October 13, 2009 at 5:54 pm
I probably watched a combined 2.5 episodes of that show over the entire run. It had its ups and doooowns. Mich grated on me,
Ian’s hubris and manner of speaking made me want to dump a bucket of icy water over his head and there were a few other things. Though, I must say, as Kenyan reality shows go, its been the most watchable thus far.
My issue with Alpha was just like yours. The guy has a great natural voice but he pushes it so much and at times he just sounds like he’s shouting in tune. I have a feeling he’d be great in Rock if he went that way. Also, I watched one or 2 short interviews he did during the show and, clearly, talent does NOT go with brains. The only way that guy is intelligent is in a National Geographic manner of speaking. *facepalm*
Sheila was awesome. She should come back if they do this again.
October 14, 2009 at 10:14 am
ALPHA DISERVED IT.THUMPS UP!!!! BUT CAROLINE STILL SHAME ON U 4 WHAT U DID 2 DEBARL.
October 14, 2009 at 12:43 pm
Am soo happy Alpha won. believe you me, i was voting for Alpha (mainly) and ngangalito on the side. not becoz Nganga had any talent, but just to keep Patricia out of the win. she got what she deserved for voting our Good Debarl! liked her before the ordeal, but after that… hater!
October 16, 2009 at 11:22 am
Thanks God her logic, and all those colleagues of hers in logic application didnt work! Pat, Debarl and Alpha were good… we shud have had a better contest from them and the fairest of them to win, but i agree its a compe!..i gree with you, dont joke with the wrath of scorned kenyans ( am one)
October 14, 2009 at 2:58 pm
I estimate EABL made no less than Ksh 50 M in 2 months from SMS votes alone (1 million votes * 50bob per SMS)
…very lucrative business and they vowed there must be TPF 4 next year…
October 17, 2009 at 6:38 am
Alpha did me proud.This TPF3 was the most fxciting.Dr Mich made it more funny.Alpha i am a very big dedicated fan of yours.God bless you.Caroline is also a big force to reckon with.N’gan’ga is a comedian.
October 17, 2009 at 2:26 pm
whoever think that patricia was the best, he/she is wrong. It is evident that she got more favour from judges, especially Judge Ian. From the fast day of the event Carolyne was seen as the potential singer, but due to (i will call it negative criticisim) from judges especially Ian, her moral of competing went down, she was just in there to entertain the crowd, from her behaviour she was very much ready to be evicted at any time. Judge Ian criticism were of no basis, at first He accused her of not smiling on the estage but that day her performance was great, i mean best, at the second time, the judges gave no reason why they put her on probation and the third time she went on probation because others were going on probation. when she sung her own composition, one of the judges said that her lyrics were familiar, i was wondering, which lyrics among all the singers were not familiar? how comes the crowd enjoyed her performance and judges were just looking what they can do pull her down? to me it was’nt a fair game for Carolyne. The game was on the favour of Patricia. Judge Ian Can tell it Well.
October 19, 2009 at 8:07 am
surely The Michael Jackson wannabe (“I remember…when we…fell in loooooove…”) the Rwandan guy with “Baby Gar Baby Gar Baby gaaaaaaaar…..oooooooh Baby Gar!” and the Ugandan rastafari (gildigildigildi..brrrrrrrrbbaba) I think they SHOULD be paid by EABL!!for being used in the adverts?